Skip to main content

Table 1 Clinical efficacy and safety of TCM for the treatment of sepsis

From: Traditional Chinese medicine for sepsis: advancing from evidence to innovative drug discovery

TCM products

Comparison

Patients

Design

Phasea

Mortality outcome

SOFA outcome

Other outcomes

References

Astragalus injection

Astragalus injection + RT vs. RT

50 patients with sepsis

RCT

II

Improved

Not assessed

Improve immune function, improve APACHE II score

[17]

Astragalus injection

Astragalus injection + RT vs. RT

60 patients with sepsis

RCT

II

No effect

No effect

Improve immune function, good safety profile

[18]

Banxia Xiexin Decoction

Banxia Xiexin Decoction + RT vs. RT

850 patients with sepsis (9 RCTs)

Meta

All phase II RCTs

Not assessed

Not assessed

Reduce gastrointestinal dysfunction score and APACHE II score

[19]

Dachaihu Decoction

Dachaihu Decoction + RT vs. RT

70 patients with sepsis

RCT

II

No effect

Improved

Improve APACHE II score, improve liver, renal, gastrointestinal function, inflammation, and coagulation, with fewer adverse events

[20]

Dachengqi Decoction

Dachengqi Decoction + RT vs. RT

68 sepsis patients with acute respiratory distress syndrome

RCT

II

No effect

Improved

Reduce inflammation markers, improve APACHE II score, shorten mechanical ventilation time, no significant difference in ICU stay

[21]

Dahuang Fuzi Decoction

Dahuang Fuzi Decoction + RT vs. RT

518 patients with sepsis (6 RCTs)

Meta

All phase II RCTs

No effect

Not assessed

Improve gastrointestinal function

[22]

Fusu Mixture

Fusu Mixture + RT vs. RT

81 patients with septic shock

RCT

II

No effect

Not assessed

Improve microcirculation parameters, shorten ICU stay

[23]

Hongyu Peizhen Formula

Hongyu Peizhen Formula + RT vs. RT

62 patients with sepsis

RCT

II

Not assessed

Improved

Improve cardiac function

[24]

HuangLian JieDu Decoction

HuangLian JieDu Decoction + RT vs. RT

115 patients with sepsis

RCT

II

Not assessed

Not assessed

Reduce inflammatory factors and APACHE II score, with no significant difference in adverse events

[25]

Jiawei Yiyi Fuzi Baijiang Powder

Jiawei Yiyi Fuzi Baijiang Powder + RT vs. RT treatment

160 patients with sepsis

RCT

II

Not assessed

Not assessed

Improve gastrointestinal function, enhance immunity, and improve nutritional status

[26]

JinHong Formula

JinHong Formula + RT vs. RT

114 patients with sepsis

RCT

II

Improved

Improved

Improve APACHE II score, reduce inflammatory markers and oxidative stress

[27]

Modified Huanglian Jiedu Decoction

Modified Huanglian Jiedu Decoction + RT vs. RT

86 patients with sepsis

RCT

II

No effect

Not assessed

Shorten length of mechanical ventilation and ICU stay, reduce incidence of hyperglycemia and gastric retention

[28]

Modified Liangge Powder

Modified Liangge Powder + RT vs. RT

143 patients with sepsis

RCT

II

Improved

Improved

Improve APACHE II score, decrease inflammatory markers

[29]

Pogejiuxin Decoction

Pogejiuxin Decoction + RT vs. RT

92 patients with septic shock

RCT

II

No effect

Improved

Reduce inflammation markers, improve lactate clearance rate, improve APACHE II score

[30]

Qiguiyin Granule

Qiguiyin Granule + RT vs. RT

60 sepsis patients with acute kidney injury

RCT

II

No effect

Not assessed

Increase renal injury recovery rate, shorten CRRT duration

[31]

Qingwen Baidu Decoction

Qingwen Baidu Decoction + RT vs. RT

86 patients with sepsis

RCT

II

Not assessed

Improved

Reduce inflammatory markers, improve endothelial function

[32]

Qingwen Baidu Decoction

Qingwen Baidu Decoction + RT vs. RT

80 patients with sepsis

RCT

II

Not assessed

Improved

Improve inflammation markers

[33]

Shenfu Injection

Shenfu Injection + RT vs. RT

4279 patients with septic shock (56 RCTs)

Meta

All phase II RCTs

Improved

Improved

Increase MAP, reduce lactate levels

[34]

Shenfu Injection

Shenfu Injection + RT vs. RT

2340 patients with sepsis and septic shock (32 RCTs)

Meta

All phase II RCTs

Improved

Improved

Increase MAP, reduce lactate levels

[35]

Shengjiang Powder

Shengjiang Powder + RT vs. RT

720 patients with sepsis (13 RCTs)

Meta

All phase II RCTs

Not assessed

Not assessed

Improve APACHE II score, decrease inflammation markers, good safety profile

[36]

Shenqi Fuzheng Injection

Shenqi Fuzheng Injection + RT vs. RT

60 patients with septic shock

RCT

II

No effect

Not assessed

Improve hemodynamics, improve APACHE II score

[37]

Shengmai Injection

Shengmai Injection + RT vs. RT

860 patients with septic shock (17 RCTs)

Meta

All phase II RCTs

No effect

Not assessed

Improve shock recovery, reduce serum lactate level

[38]

Shenmai Injection

Shenmai Injection + RT vs. RT

1469 patients with sepsis (21 RCTs)

Meta

All phase II RCTs

Improved

Not assessed

Reduce inflammatory markers, improve APACHE II score

[39]

Shenmai Injection

Shenmai Injection + RT vs. RT

583 patients with sepsis and septic shock (6 RCTs)

Meta

All phase II RCTs

Improved

Improved

Decrease lactate levels

[35]

Sini Decoction

Sini Decoction + RT vs. RT

60 patients with sepsis

RCT

II

No effect

Improved

Improve cardiac function, improved lactate clearance rate

[40]

Tuoli Xiaodu Powder

Tuoli Xiaodu Powder + RT vs. RT

57 patients with sepsis

RCT

II

No effect

Improved

Reduce inflammatory markers

[41]

Xinmailong Injection

Xinmailong Injection + RT vs. RT

192 patients with sepsis

RCT

II

No effect

Not assessed

Reduce incidence of diastolic sepsis-induced myocardial dysfunction

[42]

Xinmailong Injection

Xinmailong Injection + RT vs. RT

476 patients with sepsis (8 RCTs)

Meta

All phase II RCTs

No effect

Not assessed

Improve cardiac function, no significant effect on ICU stay, no significant adverse events reported

[43]

Xuebijing Injection

Xuebijing Injection + RT vs. RT

1817 patients with sepsis

RCT

III

Improved

Improved

Increase ICU-free days and mechanical ventilation-free days, similar adverse events

[14]

Xuebijing Injection

Xuebijing Injection + RT vs. RT

1144 patients with sepsis (16 RCTs)

Meta

All phase II RCTs

Improved

Not assessed

Improve APACHE II score, no serious adverse events

[44]

Yantiao Formula

Yantiao Formula + RT vs. RT

120 patients with sepsis

RCT

II

Not assessed

Improved

Improve gastrointestinal function

[45]

Zengye Chengqi Decoction

Zengye Chengqi Decoction + RT vs. RT

124 patients with sepsis

RCT

II

No effect

Not assessed

Reduce inflammation markers, shorten ICU stay

[46]

  1. a Phase II trials primarily aim to establish preliminary evidence of efficacy, whereas phase III trials require rigorous confirmation of clinical benefit
  2. APACHE, Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation; CI, confidence interval; CRRT, continuous renal replacement therapy; ICU, intensive care unit; RT, regular treatment; SOFA, Sequential Organ Failure Assessment; TCM, traditional Chinese medicine